[polishmafia]

You are going to have limited choices if your budget is under $1000.

Your car originally came with a 93Y load/speed rating tire. Going to a lower load/speed rating tire can cause the car's normal handling to be compromised. Don't go cheap to save a few bucks, its not worth it.

The Michelin Pilot Super Sports that Andrew mentioned are great tires, and they aren't as spendy as other tires. Just remember that you have to think about shipping and mounting/balancing costs.