Not something I'm proud of, but I'm now "uninsurable".

[Jana]

I have Progressive, and have for the last two years. I've had absolutely no problems, but haven't had any claims. They were about half the cost of Allstate for the exact same coverage. My parents also have them, and had a windshield that needed to be replaced. They called, and they people were out within just hours of them calling.

I would start with them Tauni, you can do online quotes as well.